Overall rating: 4.7387385 / 5 from 555 reviews.
The Defined Eyes Set offers a bold, striking look with its waterproof, smudge-proof eyeliner, smooth application, and rich pigment. The precision pencil sharpener ensures sharp lines, and the volumizing mascara provides all-day definition.
Review topics: ["color","quality","feel","shipping","texture","value","formula","works","look","glow","shade","use","eyes","coverage","touch","lines","skin","design","consistency","eyeliner","pencil","glides","pigment","application","smudging","sharpener","tip","brown","tugging","staying power"].
"This stuff is awesome. I'm a senior and easily bruise my shins so they always have black patches on them. Have always been self conscience in the summer time. I swim all year so that also was an issue. I purchased a color for winter and a tan color for summer. It really does the trick. . . . and I can swim and it won't come off. Very happy with this product."
"Twice I only received 1 of the 2 shades ordered in the set. I reached out to customer service and was told there was nothing they could do because the brown shade was out of stock. I asked for a refund and have been ghosted ever since. The sad thing is, I ordered the black liner and liked it, that is why I came back for the set. Westmore Beauty should make it right."
"Each time I tried to sharpen it, the colored tip broke off. When I applied it, it just smudged because the tip wasn't small enough. I love the color and have used it, but it was a bit of a disappointment. And I did try two separate pencil sharpeners."
"I used to work for Nordstrom‘s and always buy my eyeliners from there. I have never found an eyeliner that stays on like this one. I can’t believe I did get this as a free gift and I fell in love with it as much as I did."
"Smooth line and can be applied very thin or thick. The perfect black pencil staple for your cosmetic stash."
"This is a lovely eyeliner. It looks amazing on and it's not to harsh on mature eyes. It goes on so smoothly, a must have if you're a liner gal."
"The eye liner glides on super easily and has a very precise tip. However, it takes a lot of work to remove it, and you cannot use your fingertip to smudge it to make it look more natural. If you don't mind having a very sharply defined eye liner that doesn't budge, this product is for you. If you want a more natural look, I'd use something else."
"Nice color. Like the thin tip that makes whispies. Finally a color for lighter hair with no yellow in it."
"I really love this eyeliner! It glides on smoothly, it really does seem to stay on longer, plus it is WAY easier to sharpen than most eyeliner pencils and big chunks of the liner doesn't break off, as with most other eyeliners do while being sharpened! Plus, I love the gold accent on the cap since it makes it easier to find in my makeup bag. I highly recommend!!"
"I'm really happy with the color and the fact that it's fragrance free. The coverage doesn't seem as thick/opaque as the videos in the ads, but maybe I just haven't put it on thick enough. Just starting to use it more now that it's warming up outside. Love the brush as well."
